Skip to content

Guide to investing in young musicians with vision impairment

Introduction

Everyone working with children and young people with vision impairment should liaise on how to make music education accessible: the school, the local authority VI team, the music tutor, and Music Hub staff. However, through surveying Music Education Hubs in 2023, RNIB found that very few were aware of the number of children and young people with vision impairment living in the area that they cover, or were confident that they could provide appropriate support to young blind or partially sighted musicians. 

This article aims to support Hub Lead Organisations to understand the requirements of children and young people with vision impairment in their area, especially when conducting needs analyses related to Arts Council England grant spending. 

It makes some suggestions of instruments and equipment that may be especially relevant to children and young people with vision impairment, and also suggests other ways that Hubs may wish to invest to support the next generation of musicians with vision impairment. 

Conducting a needs analysis

How many children and young people with vision impairment are likely to live within my HLO’s geographical area?

RNIB’s Sight Loss Data Tool predicts that there were 24450 children (aged 0-17) with vision impairment in England in 2022. Assuming the number is similar now, with equal distribution across the 43 HLOs, this would equate to an average of ~568 children with vision impairment per HLO. However, given that the new NPME also requires Music Hubs to support young people with disabilities up to age 25, the total number of children and young people with vision impairment (VI CYP) per HLO is likely to be higher than this. 

How can I more specifically assess the need in my HLO’s geographical area? 

RNIB’s Sight Loss Data Tool shows breakdown by local authority, and importantly also breaks down the number of VI CYP into those who are partially sighted or blind. The access requirements and solutions for these groups are likely to differ.

The Department for Education also publishes data on special educational needs in England, at local authority level. However, the main tables focus on the ‘primary type of need’, meaning that the data can be misleading at first glance. For example, the headline table appears to show that there are just 9766 children with vision impairment in England. This is likely due to vision impairment occurring alongside other disabilities, which may have been considered a child’s primary type of need when the data was collected. 

It is also possible to download the dataset for secondary type of need, but this is more difficult to interpret. Some entries are missing for secondary need, and it’s possible that pupils with several types of need could have been erroneously included in the ‘multiple learning difficulty’, ‘other disability’, or ‘SEN support but no specialist assessment of need’ categories. 

The DfE’s data also does not differentiate between blind and partially sighted children, which will limit its usefulness for tailoring purchases to the VI CYP in your area.

Neither set of data includes young people aged 18-25. However, you could contact the Sensory Support Services / QTVI teams in the local authorities across your HLO’s area, who should have an idea of the VI YP that they are supporting at 18+, and their requirements.

How do I know what the children and young people with vision impairment in my Hub’s geographical area require?

Ask them! You could also contact your local authority’s Sensory Support Service / QTVI team, who should have an idea of the VI CYP that they are supporting and their requirements. You can also contact RNIB’s Music Team for general advice via RNIB Helpline: helpline@rnib.org.uk or 0303 123 9999.

Other capital grant FAQs

How do I ensure that all purchases, even ‘mainstream’ ones, are accessible to the widest range of musicians possible? 

Even for ‘mainstream’ purchases, inclusively-designed options that offer the most accessible experience to all users should be prioritised. For example, this may mean purchasing a music production or notation app that can be navigated using a keyboard and screen reader, rather than one that is not. 

As this information is not always available at retail, you may wish to search community-led websites such as Sound Without Sight and AppleVis to get an idea of how accessible a particular piece of software or hardware is. You can also contact RNIB’s Music Team for advice via RNIB Helpline: helpline@rnib.org.uk or 0303 123 9999.

However, it’s important to be aware that almost no instruments and equipment are accessible to every potential user. For example, access features developed with D/deaf users in mind, may in some cases make a product more difficult for blind or partially sighted users to interact with. 

Therefore, HLOs will be expected to work with partners to ensure that the purchases made are accessible to as many children and young people as possible, and appropriate to the need in their area. ACE will be publishing further guidance around the Local Plan for Music Education which will include information and support around both inclusion and partnership development.

The guidance includes references to purchasing “braille music machines” with the Capital Grant. What does this mean? 

There is no single “braille music machine”. This could refer to a number of devices, which all need to work together. For example:

  • Licences for notation software used to create digital scores;
  • Licences for braille translation software used to produce braille versions of digital scores;
  • Braille embossers – to ‘print’ hard-copy braille scores;
  • Digital refreshable braille displays – to enable musicians to read digital braille scores;
  • Technology that could be used to display music in other accessible ways (a tablet or iPad with suitable software etc.).
  • Compatible screen readers for the software listed above. 

What other hardware and software might be useful in supporting children and young people with vision impairment?

As everyone’s experience with sight loss is unique, there is unfortunately no one-size-fits-all equipment that can be bought to support all VI CYP. Some examples of equipment that may be suitable are given at the end of this document. 

Staff across my HLO will need training to use these items of equipment. Can that be covered by the Capital Grant?

No. Please refer to sections 4.1-4.2 of ACE’s essential information document, which outlines what isn’t eligible for purchase. However, the suppliers of specialist equipment may be able to provide training to your staff separately. If you would like support finding the right training, you can contact RNIB’s Music Team via RNIB Helpline: helpline@rnib.org.uk or 0303 123 9999.

I can’t source the specialist assistive technology I need using the Supplier Framework. Can I purchase specialist equipment by other means as an exception?

Use of the framework to purchase items with the capital grant is mandatory, but there may be rare cases where this is not possible. According to Arts Council England’s guidance, this may includes purchases that meet the following criteria:

  • “Availability: The specific instruments, equipment, or technology they require are within the scope of the grant but are not available from any of the suppliers registered with the framework. Hub Lead Organisations must provide a clear rationale for this through their Purchasing Strategy.
  • Time: The lead times for delivery through the framework would significantly delay the programme of activity and there is a need for immediate procurement to meet requirements. Hub Lead Organisations must provide a rationale for the time-sensitive nature of these purchases through their purchasing strategy and plan.   
  • Cost: While the framework aims to provide value for money, including based on cost, there may be situations where a Hub Lead Organisation identifies a lower cost for the same item outside of the framework. Hub Lead Organisations must provide a rationale through their purchasing strategy and plan, including detailing how lower cost does not compromise quality or longevity. 
  • Quality and appropriateness: Items available through the framework do not meet the specific quality standards or appropriateness required by the Hub Lead Organisation to meet the needs of children and young people. Through their Purchasing Strategy, Hub Lead Organisations must provide a rationale for why the available items are inappropriate and how the alternative option(s) better meet the needs of children and young people and support delivery of their LPME.   
  • Existing contractual obligations: An existing contractual agreement with a supplier predates the framework’s implementation. Hub Lead Organisations must document the existing contract and compare this with framework options through their purchasing strategy and plan. The Department for Education will review cases referring to this circumstance on an individual basis and advise whether cases qualify as an exception.”

Other support to consider

Capital grant aside, there are several avenues of support you could consider investing in:

Staff capacity and skills for accessible format production

  • You could consider training your staff in accessibility-friendly engraving using apps such as MuseScore and Sibelius. Notation files can then be used directly by large print readers, or translated to braille using apps such as Sao Mai Braille, which is free to use. Learn more about accessible music transcription at the RNIB Music website and the resources available at Sound Without Sight. 
  • You could also set aside a budget to use a transcription service, such as the Commercial Transcription service at RNIB or MySheetMusicTranscriptions.com.

Provision of braille music tuition

  • Where appropriate, children and young people can access specialist teaching to learn braille music code from the local authority vision impairment support service for education.
  • The Amber Trust may also be able to support with a grant for additional specialist braille music tuition outside of school.
  • It is also now possible to search for a private braille music teacher via MusicTeacher.com – just select “Braille Music Code” as the lesson type from the main dropdown box on the homepage.

VI-confident instrumental teachers

  • Of course, we believe that all private music teachers should be open to teaching blind and partially sighted pupils, but we hear it all too often that families struggle to find appropriate tuition. There are a number of ways that you may find it useful to discover music teachers who have experience with supporting the access requirements of blind or partially sighted students:
    • The Amber Trust works with a national network of teachers and even offers grants for tuition.
    • MusicTeacher.com now includes an option to filter by teachers who are confident in supporting blind or partially sighted musicians. 

VI awareness training

  • RNIB and VIEW offer a range of opportunities for professionals to meet, learn about and discuss the support of learners with vision impairment, including free and paid training. 
  • Teachers should be aware of the Curriculum Framework for Children and Young People with Vision Impairment (CFVI), which has been developed to support children and young people with vision impairment access an appropriate and equitable education.
  • To support blind and partially sighted colleagues, you may also be interested in RNIB’s Understanding Sight Loss eLearning course. 
  • RNIB can also deliver training to suit your individual requirements. Please contact our Business Services if you are interested. 
  • You could also work with other inclusive workshop leaders who have a specialism in supporting learners with vision impairment, such as Global Music Visions.
  • Sounds of Intent is an inclusive model of musical development that sets out how we all engage with music, relevant to all learners and individual access requirements.

Training for specialist equipment

  • Local authority vision impairment support services for education provides support for specialist VI skills development as appropriate to each individual. This could take the form of advice and guidance, direct delivery of training to students and the staff who work with them, or signposting to external sources of training.
  • You can also reach out to RNIB’s Music Team for help with finding further training.

Further advice

If you would like support, please reach out to RNIB’s Music Team via RNIB Helpline:

Appendix: Examples of equipment that may be suitable

Prices correct at time of writing. Use as a guide only. 

Accessible formats: pupils requiring large print

  • Some pupils will prefer to read hard-copy notation, so schools and hubs should be prepared to supply notation in large print (Modified Stave Notation). This requires the use of a notation package such as MuseScore (free) or Sibelius (£89 per licence per year) and skilled staff to use this software.
  • Simply enlarging music on a photocopier does not offer a sufficient solution and is not recommended. This is due to a reduction in print clarity, the impractical nature of large paper formats in the music classroom and the lack of customization compared to Modified Stave Notation (such as the ability to change fonts to a more accessible style). 
  • Some partially sighted pupils who need a greater level of magnification or who are dyslexic may benefit from using Modified Stave Notation in conjunction with an accessible digital sheet music app.   

Accessible formats: pupils requiring braille music

  • To produce a MusicXML file from print or PDF, staff would need to re-engrave the score using notation software, such as MuseScore (free) or Sibelius (£89 per licence per year). You may also wish to consider OMR (music scanning) software, such as capella-scan ($218) or PhotoScore (£199). However, scanned scores will need to be checked thoroughly for accuracy.
  • To produce digital braille from a MusicXML file, the school or hub would need braille music translation software such as Dancing Dots’ GOODFEEL ($1595 or subscription), Sao Mai Braille or MakeBraille. NB braille music literacy is required to check the software’s interpretation of the music.
  • To provide hard copy, the school or hub would need:
    • An embosser (the equivalent of a printer for braille). There are two main types: cut-sheet paper feed and continuous (tractor) feed. UK suppliers include RNIB and Sight and Sound.
    • Software to drive the embosser. Duxbury is the industry standard (£550)
    • An ongoing allowance for braille paper (not covered by Capital Grant).
  • For the student to read braille scores digitally, they would need access to a digital refreshable braille display.
    • A 40-cell display is recommended, such as the HumanWare BI 40X (£2000-3000), as a display of this size will show a full line of braille at a time.
    • Some pupils may prefer a more compact and portable 20-cell display. However, this will only show half a line of braille at a time.
    • Multi-line braille displays are more suitable for reading braille music scores, and viable options are slowly coming to market. 

Notation software

Screen reader friendly options include:

Digital audio workstation software

Screen reader friendly options include:

  • REAPER
  • Pro Tools
  • Logic Pro
  • Ableton Live

Studio equipment

Some VI-friendly options include:

  • Focusrite Scarlett (3rd gen onwards) and Vocaster interfaces are screen reader friendly.
  • Audient iD and EVO interfaces are screen reader friendly.
  • Softube Console 1 channel strip controller is screen reader friendly.
  • Avid S1 controller has an intuitive tactile design.
  • Native Instruments Maschine is screen reader friendly.
  • Digit Music Cmpsr has an intuitive tactile design.
  • Zoom Essential range of handheld recorders include voice guidance.
  • SSL interfaces often have an intuitive and usable design.

Keyboards

  • Most keyboards that do not rely on screens and menus for navigation are likely to be accessible. Screens and touchscreens are likely to present barriers. 
  • For MIDI controller keyboards, the Native Instruments Komplete Kontrol series and Arturia KeyLab mkII series are known to work well with screen readers. 

Plugins and software instruments

The screen reader accessibility of many plugins is improving, but particularly good examples include:

  • Native Instruments Komplete Kontrol
  • iZotope
  • Focusrite Red plugin suite
  • Audio Modeling SWAM string sections
  • Nugen Audio
  • SurgeXT synthesiser

Other considerations

  • It is essential that adequate training is provided for all the above, to avoid a situation where staff are unable to confidently use equipment purchased.
  • If using the automated transcription tools, it would be necessary to set aside additional staffing resources to check the output, using staff who are musically fluent for large print, and able to read braille music code for braille.
  • You should not assume that blind children will be braille music literate. However, you should ensure that pupils and teaching/support staff have access to additional or alternative braille music tuition to allow blind pupils to learn braille music code while their sighted peers learn stave notation.
  • Pupils who read literary braille may already have access to embossers and braille displays from other areas of education. 
  • Similarly, partially sighted pupils may already have access to a laptop or tablet.
  • Pupils will also need time and training to become confident using the software and equipment that has been purchased with their requirements in mind. This should be scheduled ahead of other planned music activities, so that the student can fully engage in the session alongside their peers.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Jay Pocknell

Jay Pocknell